Sprocket and Groupset Compatibility

Posted on
Page
of 3
/ 3
Last Next
  • My hubs have a 6 speed Shimano Uniglide Sprocket. I would like to use a Shimano 600 Ultegra groupset on my bike but as I understand, this groupset does not come in a 6 speed edition. Would I be able to fit a 7 speed cassette on the hub? Or just use a 6 speed cassette with the Shimano 600 components as 7 speed and 6 speed spacings are similar? I read Sheldon Brown's page on 'speeds' but I'm still confused.
    Thanks for any help.

  • Derailleurs are (with a couple of obscure exceptions) "dumb": they do what the shifters tell them to do. So unless you're using indexed shifters, whether the freewheels have different spacing is irrelevant.

    tl/dr
    Yes, a seven speed freewheel will fit fine.

  • It's you again! Thanks for all your help :)
    So I could in theory put a 7 speed freewheel on and use the SL-6400 shifters which are 7 speed and I will be fine?

  • I'm afraid so; I'd wait to see if it works before you thank me...

    Yes, 7 speed freewheels (almost) all have the same centre-to-centre spacing: http://sheldonbrown.com/cribsheet-spacing.html

  • I'm still pretty confused about the best course of action in my situation. My frame has a rear spacing of 126mm and my hubs are 126mm width Shimano 6 speed Uniglide 36/36. I would like to use as much of the Shimano 600 Ultegra "tricolour" groupset as possible and I'm not sure whether this will be possible with a 6 speed hub as the 6400 Derailleur is 7 speed (velobase.com/ViewComponent.aspx?I­D=c7069264-613f-48e1-8112-d3236e2fd096&E­num=108). However this build (the same frame as mine) vitus979.com/my-vitus-979/ seems to have used that derailleur on a 126mm width hub.

  • 126mm OLD is the standard for 5 to 7 speed. OLD increased to 130mm with the introduction of 8 speed.

    Hubs for screw-on freewheels aren't speed/gear specific in the same way that freehubs for cassettes are (8 speed and above): the threaded part of the hub that the freewheel screws onto is the same.

    Your current hubs will happily accept freewheels from 5 to 7 speeds.

    Have a browse through Sheldon's glossary if any of the terms aren't familiar to you.

  • The op says he has 6 speed uni glide. Silly suffolk has assumed that the op has a 6 speed freewheel which maybe correct but maybe not. The op may have a 6 speed uni glide cassette in which case finding a 7 speed cassette is hard has they are almost extinct.

    If the op use friction shifter and does fit a 7 speed cassette or freewheel then fiction shifters don't care what your sprocket spacing is. Down tube shifters should be friction

  • All shimano road mech until the new 11 speed ones have the same parallelogram design meaning they are interchangeable. A 10 speed mech can be used on 6 speed and visa versa.

  • The VeloBase page for the SL-6400 shifters say they are indexed (http://velobase.com/ViewComponent.aspx?ID=75c91ac5-4408-49e5-a9f1-d6581e1be9d5&Enum=104) I was under the impression that this meant they were not friction shifters but would be happy to be told I'm wrong :)

    EDIT: I uploaded a picture of my rear wheel to make things easier


    1 Attachment

    • WP87_Shimano_105_Golden_Arrow_-_Wolber_Gentleman_GTA_-_700c_Road_Wheels_4.jpg
  • As I understand it, this means I can use a RD-6401 even though it is supposedly 8-Speed, with a 7 speed setup?
    Thanks for your help!

  • Apart from early Dura-ace, Shimano road mechs up to 10-speed and MTB mechs up to 9-speed have the same cable pull ratio. That means that, for a given amount of cable pulled by the shifter, they'll move the same amount.

    So, with a 7-speed shifter, they'll move the distance between 7-speed sprockets, while with a 10-speed shifter they'll move the (smaller) distance between 10-speed sprockets.

    It's the shifter that controls the indexing, not the mech.

  • Silly suffolk has assumed that the op has a 6 speed freewheel which maybe correct but maybe not. The op may have a 6 speed uni glide cassette...

    "Silly" indeed: what's that about never assuming anything?

  • I uploaded a picture of my rear wheel to make things easier

    That's a freehub for a cassette, rather than a screw-on freewheel.

    From what's been said above, you'll struggle to find a 7 speed cassette.

    However, according to VB your shifters can be run either indexed or friction, so you could still use them with your 6 speed cassette.

  • Thanks everyone for your help! I'll use my 6 speed cassette for now and keep a look out for a 7 speed one :)

  • 7 speed ug cassettes are available look on ebay or post wanted adds in forums. I got one for a customer that way new as well for a chap in Finland.

  • Shimano RSX 100 7 speed STIs are afaik the only 7 speed STI set up that will run in a 126mm set up. I've used them previously on a Vitus frameset.

    I've got a nice clean set knocking about if you're interested running 7 speed ergos'

  • That sounds good, I'll message you.

  • Any shimano 7 speed shifter will index a 7 speed cassette in a 126mm frame. 7 speed spacing is just that and it does not matter the width of the dropout.

  • I am making my Cross Check into a 1x10. I have Deore 10speed cassette, derailer and chain all good - drive train is fine. I was trying to re-use the Duraace 1o speed bar end shifter I had from a road group. However it is not compatible. Googling indicates that is true.

    Can someone recommend a bar end shifter I can get that works with a 10speed MTB rear derailer? Or do I have to get a thumb shifter or downtube shifter? Is there some magic cable or gizmo that cures this issue?

    @edscoble please chime in with your wisdom

  • 10 speed MTB derailleur won't work but a 8/9 speed one will (same cable pull).

    Just get the cheapest 9 speed MTB derailleur and wack a 11-34 (or 36) cassette on and bob your uncle.

  • Thanks @edscoble - I read the 9sp compat info after I got the 10sp bits. My Duraace shifter is old which made me think it would be ok. The incompatibility was introduced in 2013, no?

    I just looked at the shimano data sheet it also says both Road and MTB, me so confused now. I think I need a 2 year+ old 10 speed derailer.

  • It's the MTB derailleur that's incompatible, unless you got the early one that have the same cable pull as the lower tier one.

  • @edscoble - So if I go get a Deore 9spd instead of the 10speed my problem goes away. What about the cassette?
    I am being told that the 10speed Deore cassette needs to be swapped to a road cassette, because of the very slight difference in spacing they introduced.

    So I am back to the road gearing I had before, since it was a Tiagra 10 Speed cassette previously.

  • Hey all,

    I realize that this is a long shot but does anyone know if a Rolf Vector Pro wheel set, which I understand is Shimano 8/9/10 compatible, takes a 7 speed rear cassette. I am trying to get a second wheel set for my vintage cross bike and the seller is not sure.
    Cheerio

  • Post a reply
    • Bold
    • Italics
    • Link
    • Image
    • List
    • Quote
    • code
    • Preview
About

Sprocket and Groupset Compatibility

Posted by Avatar for wintyDono @wintyDono

Actions