You are reading a single comment by @mashton and its replies. Click here to read the full conversation.
  • Given that this will potentially introduce comment reordering, I am concerned that the exisitng "in reply to" UI will not be up to the job.

    It is already a source of complaint for quite a few users, with the UX "jolt / context switch" of having to click and do a page reload to see the replied-to comment.

    In a thread that is dynamically reordering over time, this will become more of an issue, IMO.

    Would it be a good time to revisit this user experience?

    Also, shall we move this discussion out of this thread and into a specific one?

  • For the Q&A threads, the "reply" button will initially disappear.

    Later on, it will return and result in the replies being nested below the comment.

    Initially, each "answer" should be a stand-alone comment. For the photo competition this works fine.

About

Avatar for mashton @mashton started