I don't know, I'd say it's pretty close between those two. Scholes played on a lot of great teams. Gerrard did not.
It's hard to say how well they would have done if the roles were reversed.
Gerrard was clearly a very good player, but had some flaws. I feel Liverpool should have sold him a few years back, as we focussed on him too long, at the expense of the team.
I don't know, I'd say it's pretty close between those two. Scholes played on a lot of great teams. Gerrard did not.
It's hard to say how well they would have done if the roles were reversed.
Gerrard was clearly a very good player, but had some flaws. I feel Liverpool should have sold him a few years back, as we focussed on him too long, at the expense of the team.