You are reading a single comment by @dan and its replies.
Click here to read the full conversation.
-
You misunderstand me Gruber, I'm not saying you shouldn't make the case for Yes at all... but I've been reading this thread without posting since it began and your presence in it has been a little overbearing.
I will say however, that a lot of what you've written has been informative and you have definitely expanded my view of the debate for the better.
dan
I find you saying this troubling, Dan.
If I don't post, who is the voice of dissent? Throughout this thread I'm reading a lot of lazy generalisations and patriarchal nonsense from people who profess sincere interest-why should I not respond, and how, by responding, am I 'shouting people down'?
I'm not going to re-engage with the 'debate' here so you can rest easy, but ask yourself what exactly it is you're seeking in that: a nice, cosseted and homogenously dismissive and reductive thread where all the non-Scots can get together and stroke off over their perceived 'rightness' given to them by Tory-provoked BBC press releases from big business interventions is about all I would anticipate given the tone so far.
Enjoy it.