You are reading a single comment by @deleted and its replies. Click here to read the full conversation.
  • by suggesting and speculating that there is some secret agency at work here, you detract from the sheer banality of the evil being perpetrated and displayed in these videos and around the world, and that's an even greater tragedy.

  • I'm not denying any kind of tragedy, and this is the kind of blanket refusal to acknowledge the venal realities of the world as it is that helps perpetuate dumb horror and cynicism. As for the banality of evil, Saudi Arabia's decapitated more people this year than ever for actions that wouldn't even get community service in the UK.

    I don't see how challenging a mass media narrative on a cycling forum changes this fact, and that's even before you contradict yourself by saying I'm 'detracting' from 'banality'. If its so boring or mundane how exactly is this event so significant in the development of US policy in Iraq as it forces them to re-engage with military action?

    It seems naive to refuse to consider that all kinds of people have a vested interest in how this event plays out in the media with its resulting effects in steering political action, and will capitalise on it the best way they can to steer the narrative their way, even if it means faking a video or two as a means to achieve a wider goal.

    James Foley is dead either way, and for those who knew and loved him that's tragic, I don't think anyone would disagree with that.

  • If its so boring or mundane how exactly is this event so significant in the development of US policy in Iraq as it forces them to re-engage with military action?

    The beheading took place after the US had already engaged in military action in Iraq. The atrocities committed by ISIS have been regularly in the news this year*. The events in Iraq would have served as a sufficient justification anyway if Obama had decided that it's something he wants to do**.

    *Tinfoil translation: the Western Propaganda Campaign.
    **Tinfoil translation: the Economic Powers whose puppet Obama is.

About

Avatar for deleted @deleted started