+1. Was going to recommend Macallan myself, particularly over Highland Park. Macallan is a classic, a fine example of the character of that region and they know how to look after it. Highland Park used to be a classic and they fucked it up. Also, the quality is hugely variable.
As for Laphroaig, I do like it but it's also a bit of a novelty whisky. Introductory only in a "come and have a go if you think you're hard enough" sense. Hence very popular with students and heavy smokers. If you want to try out Islay whiskies, maybe start with Bowmore.
+1. Was going to recommend Macallan myself, particularly over Highland Park. Macallan is a classic, a fine example of the character of that region and they know how to look after it. Highland Park used to be a classic and they fucked it up. Also, the quality is hugely variable.
As for Laphroaig, I do like it but it's also a bit of a novelty whisky. Introductory only in a "come and have a go if you think you're hard enough" sense. Hence very popular with students and heavy smokers. If you want to try out Islay whiskies, maybe start with Bowmore.